Rx
moral Viagra
july 17, 2000. The Planning Commission received a few
knuckle raps last week.
Ever the graceful politician, Supervisor
Gavin Newsom delivered his blows with politesse: "The
Board of Supervisors increasingly is being put in the
position of adjudicating planning issues…. we have become
not just the last resort, but the only resort, for a public
that’s lost faith in our planning process."
Veteran housing advocate Sue Hestor really
let the ruler fly: "You are the most impotent body I’ve
ever seen."
The malady under scrutiny is not a trendy
erectile dysfunction but a good old-fashioned case of
shooting blanks. The Planning Commission is failing to
produce plans. Any building plans you see walking down the
street must be the result of an illicit liaison with another
father. You might look carefully for family resemblances.
Newsom and Hestor’s frustration perches
precariously on the lip of a smoldering volcano. San
Francisco’s housing crisis heats up daily — the
California Association of Realtors announced Thursday that
only 10 percent of the city’s households can afford to buy
a median-priced home. Eruption is imminent, as 500 people
from the Mission and elsewhere tried to make clear outside
the Planning Commission meeting on the same day.
Inside, however, commission president
Anita Theoharis held sway, and rudeness ruled. The Mission
Anti-Displacement Coalition had put together a delegation to
present its case before the commissioners and the crowded
meeting room. The first speaker set a serious tone, asking
for a moment of silence in memory of those who will die on
the streets for lack of housing. The six delegates clasped
their hands and looked toward the floor.
Theoharis called the next speaker.
"I asked for a moment of
silence."
"I’m sorry," she replied.
"The acoustics are terrible here; I didn’t hear what
you said." She called again for the next speaker.
The delegates stood silent.
Theoharis began sputtering names, calling
the next speaker, and the next, and the next, until at last
one of the delegates stepped up to the microphone and
presented their proposal.
It’s a simple one, born of a recognition
that the city’s stampeding economy is turning far too many
of the present residents from their homes because they
cannot afford to pay market rates. In essence, it says, don’t
do anything without thinking about the consequences. It
calls for
(1) a moratorium on all market-rate
housing development;
(2) a moratorium on all multimedia
development;
(3) an abatement of illegal
conversions of existing buildings;
(4) a community-based rezoning of the
Mission District, with a provision for the rezoning in
the 2000-2001 budget.
A simple proposal, concisely argued.
Perhaps rattled by the applause that greeted each speaker,
Theoharis did her best to prevent the presentation from
proceeding smoothly, lecturing the audience on its
intrusions and interrupting one of the speakers to chide the
owner of a cell phone. (When another cell phone rang during
a later discussion, it apparently didn’t bother her enough
to disrupt the speaker’s train of thought.)
A simple proposal, concisely argued. A far
cry from Planning Director Gerald Green’s report that
followed, pulling out all the stops: The coalition’s
passion is not directed in the right place…. The situation
is the result of unusual economic changes across the nation,
not just locally…. I can’t understand why in this time
of housing crisis, we’d consider a moratorium on
market-rate housing…. Clearly, land use contributes to
change in the city, but others do as well…. You should
express your passion to the wider city family…. I would
direct you to the Board of Supervisors.
Responding with shouts of
"Bullshit!" and "We’ll be back," the
coalition’s supporters left the room. In fact, guards
herded the entire audience from the room, presumably as
punishment for their rowdy behavior. The commissioners took
the time to stretch their legs, eat a sandwich, chat among
themselves.
When they reconvened, Commissioner Beverly
Mills politely requested Green to schedule a hearing on the
proposed moratoriums, with a date to be set by the next
commission meeting. And then the business of the day began
in earnest. At the outset, Commissioner Dennis Antenore
suggested they require developers who demolish affordable
housing to replace it either with funds or with other
housing. "If we don’t, we are failing to respond to
what everyone has said today and in the past weeks."
The commission promptly approved one item after another that
would only intensify the churning in the neighborhoods:
360 10th Street, between Folsom
and Harrison. Demolish two dwelling units and construct six
new live/work units. Passed, with Antenore, Joe, and Martin
dissenting.
673-683 Brannan Street / 168-178 Bluxome
Street. Demolish an existing 10,000 square foot warehouse
and construct four new buildings containing 177 live/work
units and 177 parking spaces. Each structure will be 55 feet
tall; they will cover the full length and width of the block
from 5th to 6th Street. Passed, with
Antenore, Joe, and Martin dissenting.
1247 Harrison Street, between 8th
and 9th Streets. Demolish the existing building
and construct three new live/work buildings containing 64
units. Passed, with Antenore and Joe dissenting.